ActionAdventure
Mafia: Definitive Edition
Give it 5 hours
Gets good by 5h then rated almost like by veterans
Fully opens up by 10h rated like by long-time players
Reach the ending 54% of players who started
Started playing 92% of owners
Steam reviews 87% positive of 111,909
What the data shows
- In the first 2 hours 1 in 2 reviews are negative (46%); after 10h it's 1 in 14 (7%).
- Fully opens up by hour 10.
- 54% of players who start reach the ending.
- 92% of owners got the first achievement.
When it gets good
Share of positive reviews by how many hours the reviewer had played when writing the review.
before it gets good opening up fully opened up
Based on all 112,729 Steam reviews in every language. Median playtime in a sample of 296 reviews: 11.2h for positive, 7h for negative. Almost every game is rated lower in the first 2–3 hours: that window includes refunds and quick first impressions. What matters is how deep the dip is and how fast the game recovers.
Where players quit
Share of players who started the game and reached each story milestone. 100% is the most common achievement (92.4% of owners), so people who bought the game and never launched it don't count.
- Started playing 100%
- A Chase through the Night Completed "An Offer You Can't Refuse" 100%
- The Back Streets of Little Italy Completed "Running Man" 95% −5
- The Way this City Works Completed "Molotov Party" 90% −4
- Gangs of Lost Heaven Completed "Ordinary Routine" 85% −6
- Neighborhood Hero Completed "Fair Play" Most players quit here 77% −8
- Good Night for a Walk Anyways Completed "Sarah" 76% −1
- Storm Cloud over Chinatown Completed "Better Get Used to It" 75% −2
- Murder in the House of God Completed "The Saint and the Sinner" 71% −3
- Your Canuck Cousins Completed "A Trip to the Country" 68% −4
- Rat in the House Completed "Omerta" 66% −2
- Blood on Beech Hill Completed "Visiting Rich People" 64% −2
- Best Laid Plans Completed "Great Deal" 62% −1
- The Day the War Began Completed "Bon Appétit" 62% −1
- Death on the Water Completed "Happy Birthday" 61% −1
- When God Stops Smiling Completed "You Lucky ..." 59% −1
- The Day the War Ended Completed "Crème de la Crème" 59% −1
- A View from the Top Completed "Election Campaign" 57% −1
- Into the Lion's Den Completed "Just For Relaxation" 55% −2
- That Last Big Score Completed "Moonlighting" 54%
- Friends and Family Completed "The Death of Art" 54%
story milestone ending biggest drop-off
Story milestones were labeled by AI from achievement names and descriptions; mistakes are possible.
All achievements (43)
story milestone ending side
- A Chase through the Night Completed "An Offer You Can't Refuse" 100%
- The Back Streets of Little Italy Completed "Running Man" 95%
- Family History Found a 'Gangsters of the United States' cigarette card 91%
- The Way this City Works Completed "Molotov Party" 90%
- Pulp Fiction Found a Pulp Magazine 87%
- Gangs of Lost Heaven Completed "Ordinary Routine" 85%
- Supercharged Won the race 78%
- Neighborhood Hero Completed "Fair Play" 77%
- Good Night for a Walk Anyways Completed "Sarah" 76%
- Storm Cloud over Chinatown Completed "Better Get Used to It" 75%
- Murder in the House of God Completed "The Saint and the Sinner" 71%
- Your Canuck Cousins Completed "A Trip to the Country" 68%
- Rat in the House Completed "Omerta" 66%
- Blood on Beech Hill Completed "Visiting Rich People" 64%
- Best Laid Plans Completed "Great Deal" 62%
- The Day the War Began Completed "Bon Appétit" 62%
- Comic Violence Found a copy of Gangsters Monthly 61%
- Death on the Water Completed "Happy Birthday" 61%
- When God Stops Smiling Completed "You Lucky ..." 59%
- The Day the War Ended Completed "Crème de la Crème" 59%
- A View from the Top Completed "Election Campaign" 57%
- Into the Lion's Den Completed "Just For Relaxation" 55%
- That Last Big Score Completed "Moonlighting" 54%
- Friends and Family Completed "The Death of Art" 54%
- A Life of Crime Completed the game on Easy, Medium, or Hard difficulty 54%
- Quite the Collection Collected 15 vehicles in the Garage 51%
- Heat from the Cops Lost the cops after accruing a five star police chase 46%
- Lined Pockets Paid a fine to the Lost Heaven Police Department 23%
- Mystery Fox Discovered Found a Mystery Fox 17%
- Not Taken In Resisted arrest by the Lost Heaven Police Department 16%
- Car Enthusiast Lockpicked 5 cars on the streets of Lost Heaven and environs 14%
- That Motor can Move Reached 50mph while driving the Bolt Ace 7.8%
- Made Man Completed the game on Classic difficulty 7.7%
- On the Trail Found a hidden car 6.8%
- Not Classy Took Paulie to a Place of Disrepute 6.4%
- Car Thief Number One Found all of the hidden cars 5.7%
- Stunt Rider Performed a wheelie for 3 seconds 5.6%
- Motor Museum Collected 30 vehicles in the Garage 4.2%
- Full Set Found all 'Gangsters of the United States' cigarette cards 3.5%
- Lending Library Found all Pulp Magazines 3.2%
- Picture Book Connoisseur Found all copies of Gangsters Monthly 3.2%
- The Whole Story Completed the Collection 3.2%
- Mystery Fox Domination Found all Mystery Foxes 3.1%
Steam page Updated: 2026-10-20.